Key Lime Pie Online Store

Buy Key Lime Pie Online

NOW SHIPPING OVERNIGHT WITH NEXT DELIVERY WITHIN THE STATE OF FLORIDA!

Florida residents can now order your own slice of “paradise” right here on our web site! Our frozen Key Lime Pies and Tropical Cheesecakes are available to be shipped within the State of Florida for next day delivery via UPS in our specially designed insulated cooled packaging to ensure safe and fresh delivery.

Unfortunately, due to increased fuel costs and fuel surcharges, shipping is currently available only in the State of Florida. However, if you live outside the State of Florida and would like to buy our Florida Key Lime Pie and Tropical Cheesecakes click here for alternate ordering options.

In order to guarantee your Key Lime Pies or Tropical Cheesecakes will still be frozen on delivery, we can only ship Monday-Thursday. All orders placed after 10 a.m. (Eastern Time) will be filled the next day.

We accept MasterCard, Visa, American Express, Discover, PayPal and most bank cards.

Solution GraphicsAll transactions are handled securely using the PayPal shopping system.

For more information about shipping methods and a breakdown of our shipping and handling costs see our shipping information section.

If you have any questions about purchasing or shipping, please feel free to contact us!

 

Traditional 10” Key Lime Pie

Our deliciously tart and creamy traditional Florida Key Lime Pie is freshly prepared from a long standing South Florida family recipe. Baked daily, our pies are quick-frozen and delivered to you in our specially constructed insulated cooler to let you enjoy the fresh taste of Florida at home!

Size: 10”
Weight: 40 oz.
Portions: 8 or 12 slices


One Pie for $69.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)


Two Pies for $135.95 (Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

 

One of a kind
"Key Lime Pie in a Cup"

Now you can enjoy Key Lime Pie on the go! Each package contains twelve of our individually packaged "Key Lime Pie in a Cup", complete with a graham cracker crust layer and whipped cream topping. Perfect for picnics or the travel cooler, or as a convenient treat for one!


Portions: Twelve (12)
individual 4.0 oz. cups


Twelve Cups for $79.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

 

“Restaurant Style”
Deep Dish Key Lime Pie

Our Deep Dish "Restaurant Style" pie features a thick graham crust and extra-deep Florida Key Lime filling. This pie is pre-cut with paper dividers for easy serving.


Size: 9”
Weight: 40 oz.
Portion: 8 slices
(pre-portioned)


One Pie for $69.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)


Two Pies for $135.95 (Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

 

Caribbean Chocolate Marble
Cheesecake

Our rich and creamy Caribbean Chocolate Marble Cheesecake with a chocolate-crumb crust. Made from the finest imported Belgian Chocolate, this Cheesecake is sure to please the palate of chocolate lovers everywhere!


Size: 9”
Weight: 40 oz.
Portion: 8 or 12 slices


One Cheesecake for $69.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)


Two Cheesecakes for $135.95 (Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

 

Island Mango Cheesecake

Our delicious Island Mango Cheesecake is as refreshing and delightful as an island breeze. Made with real Mango fruit, this prized dessert is sure to be a favorite treat for everyone!


Size: 9”
Weight: 40 oz.
Portions: 8 or 12 slices


One Cheesecake for $69.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)


Two Cheesecakes for $135.95 (Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

 

Tropical Guava Cheesecake

Treat yourself to our delightfully robust Tropical Guava Cheesecake, baked fresh and made with real Guava. Your first bite will have you convinced you are enjoying a unique tropical island specialty!


Size: 9”
Weight: 40 oz.
Portions: 8 or 12 slices


One Cheesecake for $69.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)


Two Cheesecakes for $135.95 (Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

 

Vanilla Bean Cheesecake

Our prized Vanilla Bean Cheesecake is made with the finest vanilla beans available. This is an especially fine dessert for anyone to enjoy!


Size: 10”
Weight: 40 oz.
Portions: 8 or 12 slices


One Cheesecake for $69.95
(Includes Shipping and Handling)


Two Cheesecakes for $135.95 (Includes Shipping and Handling)

 

Shipping and Handling Information

What goes into shipping our Florida Key Lime Pies and Tropical Cheesecakes? Baked daily, our pies and cheesecakes are quick-frozen and delivered to you in our specially designed insulated coolers. These coolers contain dry ice and insulated packing fillers to keep the pies perfectly frozen and safe, no matter what part of the State you need them shipped to.

When placing your order please include a valid telephone number and, if different from your own, that of the recipient.

We recommend removing your Florida Key Lime Pie or Tropical Cheesecake from the foam shipping cooler and immediately placing it in your freezer. Thaw in refrigerator 2-4 hours before serving.

Here is a breakdown of what is included in our shipping and handling charge:

Special Fitted Foam Cooler - $10.00
Form-cut Dry Ice - $9.50
Packaging Cost - $5.00
UPS Overnight Shipping - $25

Island Mango Cheesecake! Tropical Guava Cheesecake Fresh from Florida Florida Restaurant & Lodging AssociationCocoa Beach Chamber of Commerce
National Restaurant Association Member
Fishbowl
Partner

Freshly Made By Floridians in Florida
The Florida Key Lime Pie is designated as the Official State Pie of the State of Florida